Gaza: the wrongs and rights of killing civilians.


The Economist questions the proportionality of Israel's response to the Hamas rocket attacks:

In the arithmetic of death, the latest fight between Israel and Hamas has been an unequal contest: more than 350 Palestinians killed in Israeli air strikes in the first four days, many of them civilians, against four Israelis killed by Hamas’s rockets. But does such one-sided bloodshed make Israel guilty of using “disproportionate force”, as argued by, among others, Amnesty International and Nicolas Sarkozy, the French president, just ending his six-month presidency of the European Union?

Proportionality is intimately bound up with notions of the just war, and has been enshrined in treaties regulating warfare’s conduct since the Hague Convention of 1907. But familiar as it is, proportionality is a slippery idea. It has two different meanings in Western theory. On the grounds for going to war, jus ad bellum, the cause must be important enough to justify force; any good that will follow must outweigh the inevitable pain and destruction. In the conduct of war, jus in bello, any action must weigh the military gain against the likely harm to civilians. (Full)

This is the more to be questioned as today two UN schools were hit by Israeli missiles, killing over 30 people.

Maxwell Gaylard, the U.N. humanitarian coordinator for the occupied Palestinian territory, issued a statement saying:

"These tragic incidents need to be investigated, and if international humanitarian law has been contravened, those responsible must held accountable." (Full)

Meanwhile, Israel insisted there is no humanitarian crisis for the Palestinians living in Gaza, a statement contradicted by the UN humanitarian chief:

"This is, in our view, a humanitarian crisis. It's very hard for me to see any other way you could describe it, given the conditions in which the population are living." (Full)

Check the latest UN situation report on Gaza.
Join the discussion thread about Gaza on The Road's forum.

Discovered via AidNews
Picture courtesy Muhammed Muheisen/AP Photo


Anonymous,  07 January, 2009 13:49  

Thanks a lot Peter, I'll take a look at the link you suggested. No, I don't think this sort of work gets any easier - I am struggling with the 'dealing with it' bit; either that or call it a day. I don't know. It plays havoc with every aspect of your life yet it is addictive and thrilling, like a drug I imagine. Thanks for stopping by.

Paddy in BA (Quickroute) 07 January, 2009 19:39  

Watching this unfold over the past few weeks has been extremely disturbing. Interestingly it's brought a lot of people who were either oblivious or who were sitting on the fence, out in the open voicing their utter disgust for the situation

Afro-Asian People's Democratic Islamic Congress (APIC[APICONG]) 22 March, 2011 02:12  

Heavy air strikes on Gaza: 19 civilian casualties, among them children.
We sharply condemn this aggression which, in reality, is not a response to HAMAS but to the sustained protests of Palestine's youth for national unity and democratic rights.

Read our full statement on

Post a Comment

To avoid spamming and profanity, comments will only show up after I (manually) clear them.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Kind people supporting The Road to the Horizon:
Find out how you can sponsor The Road

  © Blogger template The Business Templates by 2008

Back to TOP